Skip to content
Saturday, 14 November 2026 Today’s Dispatch
Ask
Sat 14 Nov 2026
Nineteenth-century print of a snowy colonial street on Christmas Eve: a gentleman in a tricorn bows to a lady stepping from a sedan chair, while couples greet each other at a doorway hung with a lantern and greenery.
"Christmas Eve in colonial times", print, c. 1892. Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division, LCCN 2003666980; no known restrictions on publication. Public domain.
Dispatch · IV.OR.STRU.01

The Christmas Canon Admits New Songs, a Decade Late

At the peak of the 2025 holiday season, songs written after 1994 held 17 of the 100 places on Billboard's streaming chart of holiday music, and two of the top ten. The new songs that endure took years to reach their highest positions, and investors bought into the standards after the charts had confirmed them. The evidence fits a canon set by a recorded style and handed down between generations, which the December charts amplify and capital follows.

10 November 2026 · 17 min read

At the peak of the 2025 holiday season, songs written after 1994 held 17 of the 100 places on Billboard’s streaming chart of holiday music, and two of the top ten. The new songs that endure took years to reach their highest positions, and investors bought into the standards after the charts had confirmed them. The evidence fits a canon set by a recorded style and handed down between generations, which the December charts amplify and capital follows.

In the Billboard Hot 100 dated 3 January 2026, the chart that reflects Christmas week, holiday songs held the top 24 places, led by Mariah Carey’s “All I Want for Christmas Is You” of 1994 in a record 22nd week at No. 1.1 A week before Christmas, a fund advised by a private credit manager had bought a minority interest in that song’s royalty rights.2

Christmas music in the United States runs on an old canon that admits new songs slowly, and its top places rarely. At the peak of the 2025 season, 17 of the 100 most-streamed holiday songs had been written after 1994, two of them in the top ten, and the new songs that endure took years to rise. Holiday songs have taken a growing share of the December charts, investors bought in after the charts had confirmed the standards’ value, and the evidence fits a style handed down between generations better than selection by playlists or owners.

Three tests can falsify this reading on available data.

  • Entry. The claim fails if songs written after 1994 hold a third or more of the Holiday 100 at the season’s peak, or three or more of its top ten places.
  • Mechanism. If owners or streaming services selected the canon, purchases of rights should precede the songs’ rise, and streaming’s gains should go to promoted recordings of any age. If the canon came first, purchases should follow chart success and the gains should go to old recordings.
  • Scope. The claim must hold for compositions and for recordings, at the top of the chart and below it, and for songs released at different times.

The first test passes. The second favours the canon coming first, with one limit set out in the counter-argument below. The third narrows the claim: the canon admits new compositions rarely and slowly, admits new recordings of old songs readily, and has been tested here only for the United States.

These tests address a common reading of the December charts, which holds that the standards were fixed between the 1940s and 1994, that new songs no longer join them, and that seasonal playlists, algorithmic repetition and the owners of the catalogues keep the list closed. Billboard’s Holiday 100, which ranks holiday songs by streaming activity tracked by the data company Luminate, placed Carey’s song first for the same week, followed by Brenda Lee’s “Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree” of 1958 and Bobby Helms’s “Jingle Bell Rock” of 1957.3

This Dispatch opens Titanica’s Orpheus Domain, whose subject is music as an industry, a technology and a shared memory. Christmas music is the part of popular music where all three are easiest to see at once.

What the December chart measures

The Holiday 100 is a weekly ranking that Billboard publishes during the holiday season. Its methodology line states that it is ranked by streaming activity data from online music sources tracked by Luminate.3 It therefore measures plays on streaming services and excludes radio airplay and sales. The chart for the week of 3 January 2026 is the one that reflects Christmas week 2025. The chart page lists, for each entry, its position the previous week, its peak position, the number of weeks it has spent on the chart and, for many entries, the date and position of its debut. The earliest debut date shown is 10 December 2011. The largest number of weeks on the chart shown is 79, held by 22 entries, among them Wham!’s “Last Christmas”, which debuted on that first date.

Spotify’s daily global chart for December 2025 was not accessible for this Dispatch, and the Spotify figures for that month reported in the press could not be traced to a primary source. This Dispatch uses the Billboard chart as its primary dataset and does not rely on Spotify figures.

Titanica coded each of the 100 entries by two dates: the year in which the song was written, and the year in which the charted recording was released. The two differ often. Nat King Cole’s “The Christmas Song” was written in the 1940s; the version on the chart is his 1961 recording. Michael Bublé’s “It’s Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas” was written in 1951 and recorded for his 2011 album. Twelve entries appear on the chart page without a title in the version Titanica retrieved. Eleven were identified from their songwriter and label credits, which the page does show; the twelfth, credited to S. A. Carpenter, J. C. Bunetta and S. Jones, debuted on 13 December 2025 and is counted as a song written after 1994. Exact years are uncertain for a handful of older recordings, but none of the uncertain cases falls near the 1994 line that the tests use.

IV · THE CULTURE — ORPHEUS

Songs written after 1994 hold two of the top 25 places, and none between 11 and 25.
Billboard Holiday 100, week of 3 January 2026: entries by year the song was written, by chart position
PositionsBefore 1930 (traditional)1930–19591960–19791980–19941995–2025Share written after 1994
1–100512220%
11–25276000%
26–5001170728%
51–10082383816%
All 10010462251717%
Source: Billboard, Holiday 100, week of 3 January 2026 (ranked by streaming data tracked by Luminate). Years of composition coded by Titanica from the songs’ publication histories; counts and shares computed by Titanica. “1995–2025” includes two arrangements of older material credited as new works by Trans-Siberian Orchestra. · Exhibit 01 · IV.OR.STRU.01

The distribution is uneven in a specific way. Songs written between 1930 and 1959 account for 46 of the 100 entries, close to half, and for five of the top ten. Songs written after 1994 account for 17 entries. Two of them are in the top ten: Ariana Grande’s “Santa Tell Me” at No. 5 and Kelly Clarkson’s “Underneath the Tree” at No. 8. None of the 15 places from No. 11 to No. 25 is held by a song written after 1994. The newer songs cluster between No. 26 and No. 50, where they hold seven places, and in the lower half of the chart.

Half of the entries were written in 1954 or earlier, and half were recorded in 1966 or earlier. The median recording in the top ten dates from 1963. The 1940s supply more entries than any other decade of composition, 22, followed by the 1950s with 18 and the 1960s with 17. On the entry test, the claim holds: songs written after 1994 make up 17 per cent of the chart and two of its top ten, below the thresholds set in advance. The number is small, and it is larger than zero. A canon that admitted nothing after 1994 would show no entries in the last column, and the chart shows 17.

Recorded after 1994, written before it

The picture changes when the chart is read by recording. Of the 100 entries, 27 are recordings released after 1994. Ten of those 27 are new recordings of songs written earlier: five by Michael Bublé, all from his 2011 album Christmas, three by the vocal group Pentatonix, one by John Legend and one by the singer Laufey. The remaining 17 are new songs.

IV · THE CULTURE — ORPHEUS

Ten of the 27 recent recordings on the chart are new versions of old songs.
Billboard Holiday 100, week of 3 January 2026: entries by year the charted recording was released, and recordings after 1994 by type
Year of recordingEntriesOf which in top 25Note
1940–19592610Includes Bing Crosby’s 1947 “White Christmas”
1960–19793910Includes Nat King Cole’s 1961 “The Christmas Song” and the Ronettes’ 1963 “Sleigh Ride”
1980–199482Mariah Carey (1994) and Wham! (1984) in the top 4
1995–200950All five are new songs
2010–202522312 new songs and 10 new recordings of older songs
Recordings after 1994: 27 in all, of which 17 new songs and 10 new versions of songs written before 1995 (Michael Bublé 5, Pentatonix 3, John Legend 1, Laufey 1)
Source: Billboard, Holiday 100, week of 3 January 2026. Recording years coded by Titanica from the release histories of the charted versions; counts computed by Titanica. · Exhibit 02 · IV.OR.STRU.01

This distinction matters for the working thesis. The canon is closed most firmly to new compositions. It is open to new performers of old compositions, provided the new recording keeps the older sound. Bublé’s album, released in 2011, places five tracks on the chart 14 years later, and his “It’s Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas” stands at No. 13, the highest of any recording made after 2009 apart from the two new songs in the top ten. Its song was written by Meredith Willson in 1951, and the chart shows two other recordings of it, by Perry Como with the Fontane Sisters at No. 18 and by Bing Crosby at No. 84.

The same song appearing in several versions is common on the chart. Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas appears three times, in recordings by Frank Sinatra, Bublé and Judy Garland. Christmas (Baby Please Come Home) appears three times, by Darlene Love, Carey and Bublé. A new recording of an old song is a way of entering the canon without changing it. On the scope test, the claim of a closed canon holds for compositions and fails for recordings.

How new songs enter

The 17 newer songs on the chart did not arrive in the same way. The chart page records each entry’s debut date and position and the date it reached its peak, which makes it possible to see when each song did its best.3 Two patterns appear.

IV · THE CULTURE — ORPHEUS

Some new songs peaked in their first season and fell; others rose for years.
Selected songs written after 1990 on the Billboard Holiday 100: debut, peak and position in the week of 3 January 2026
Song, artist (year released)Debut on Holiday 100Peak position (date)Position, 3 Jan 2026Weeks on chart
“All I Want for Christmas Is You”, Mariah Carey (1994)not shown1179
“Underneath the Tree”, Kelly Clarkson (2013)No. 34, 14 Dec 20136 (29 Nov 2025)869
“Snowman”, Sia (2017)No. 72, 8 Jan 202231 (29 Nov 2025)3824
“Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays”, *NSYNC (1998)No. 90, 14 Dec 201337 (9 Jan 2016)6268
“Where Are You Christmas?”, Faith Hill (2000)No. 16, 10 Dec 201115 (17 Dec 2011)9076
“Cozy Little Christmas”, Katy Perry (2018)No. 43, 8 Dec 201830 (5 Jan 2019)5444
“Like It’s Christmas”, Jonas Brothers (2019)No. 25, 7 Dec 201918 (28 Dec 2019)2639
“Christmas Tree Farm”, Taylor Swift (2019)No. 19, 21 Dec 201919 (21 Dec 2019)6827
Source: Billboard, Holiday 100, week of 3 January 2026; debut and peak data as shown on the chart page. Years of release from the songs’ release histories. “Not shown”: the page gives no debut data for the entry. · Exhibit 03 · IV.OR.STRU.01

In the first pattern, a song by an established star enters high in its first season, reaches its peak within weeks and then declines. Taylor Swift’s “Christmas Tree Farm” entered at No. 19 in December 2019, which remains its peak; it stood at No. 68 six years later. The Jonas Brothers’ “Like It’s Christmas” and Katy Perry’s “Cozy Little Christmas” followed the same course, peaking in their first season; they stood at No. 26 and No. 54 in the week of 3 January 2026. Faith Hill’s “Where Are You Christmas?”, from 2000, peaked in the chart’s first weeks in December 2011 and has fallen to No. 90.

In the second pattern, a song rises slowly and does its best long after release. Kelly Clarkson’s “Underneath the Tree” was released in 2013 and entered the Holiday 100 at No. 34; its peak of No. 6 came on the chart dated 29 November 2025, twelve years later. On the Hot 100 it reached No. 7 in the week of 27 December 2025, Clarkson’s highest position on that chart since “Stronger (What Doesn’t Kill You)”.4 Sia’s “Snowman”, released in 2017, first appeared on the Holiday 100 in January 2022, more than four years after release, and set its peak in November 2025. Ariana Grande’s “Santa Tell Me”, released in 2014, reached No. 5 on the Hot 100 in the chart dated 4 January 2025, which a chart analyst described as the first time a holiday song from the 21st century had reached the top five.5 It held No. 5 a year later.1

The slowest climb belongs to the song at the top. “All I Want for Christmas Is You” was released in 1994 and first reached No. 1 on the Hot 100 in December 2019, 25 years later, according to the Associated Press.6 The Holiday 100 does not cover the years before 2011, so the climb cannot be traced week by week. Its length is clear from the two end points. The Christmas song written in the past half century that has spent most weeks at No. 1 took a generation to become the season’s leading record.

That timing is consistent with a finding in the psychology of music. In a study published in Psychological Science in 2013, Carol Krumhansl and J. A. Zupnick played 62 young adults two top hits from each year between 1955 and 2009 and measured their memories, recognition, liking and emotional responses.7 All measures peaked for music from the participants’ own youth, and they peaked again for music from their parents’ youth, which the authors linked to hearing that music at home in childhood. They called the pattern “cascading reminiscence bumps”. The study was not about Christmas music. Its finding describes how a song heard in childhood becomes a song a listener later chooses, which is the route by which “Underneath the Tree” could become a standard for those who were children in 2013.

Why the standards sound alike

The performing-rights organisation ASCAP publishes each December a list of the most-played holiday songs written by its members, by its own measure of performances. Its list for 2025 names 25 songs.8 Seventeen of them were written between 1934 and 1959. Two were written in the 1930s, seven in the 1940s and eight in the 1950s. Johnny Marks wrote three of the 25, “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer” (1949), “Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree” (1958) and “A Holly Jolly Christmas” (1962), and co-wrote a fourth, “Run Rudolph Run” (1958). The newest songs on the list are “All I Want for Christmas Is You” (1994) and two songs from 2013, “Santa Tell Me” and “Underneath the Tree”. The writers named include Irving Berlin, Sammy Cahn and Jule Styne, Mel Tormé and Robert Wells, Meredith Willson, and Leroy Anderson and Mitchell Parish, the generation of professional songwriters associated with Tin Pan Alley, Broadway and the Hollywood musical. ASCAP’s list covers only its own members’ works, so it omits songs registered elsewhere, but its shape matches the streaming chart: a block of mid-century compositions with a small, recent addition.

ASCAP also publishes a separate list of ten “new classic” holiday songs. For 2025, the songs on it date from 2000 to 2023, led by “Santa Tell Me”, “Underneath the Tree” and Justin Bieber’s “Mistletoe” (2011).8

Music theorists disagree about whether the standards share a harmonic language. Analyses of Carey’s song published in 2018 emphasised its harmony: Classic FM described its “sumptuous chromaticism” and reported that the song, in G major, uses 13 distinct chords according to a musicologist quoted by Slate, and that Slate and Vox attributed its festive sound to a half-diminished chord under the word “presents”.9 Megan Lavengood argued the opposite case on her website in 2016: that the harmonies of Christmas songs “don’t sound particularly Christmassy”, that harmony “is not different in Christmas music than in comparable pop styles”, and that the seasonal character comes from lyrics and timbre. She cited the harmony of Band Aid’s “Do They Know It’s Christmas?” as an example of a progression with nothing seasonal about it.10

An analysis published in December 2025 also placed the weight on timbre. Samuel J. Bennett, a senior lecturer in music production at Nottingham Trent University, wrote that sleigh bells have long served composers as shorthand for Christmas, from Prokofiev’s Troika of 1933 to “Santa Tell Me”, and that bell sounds appear in most of the 40 most-streamed Christmas songs in the United Kingdom.11 He identified two other markers: a crooning voice over light orchestral accompaniment, in the manner of Bing Crosby and Nat King Cole, and a repertoire of reinterpreted classics, which makes new albums sound familiar. He described Bublé’s 2011 album as meeting every one of those conditions, and argued that such sounds feel old rather than modern. Bennett noted that Carey’s song opens with a glockenspiel-like introduction, and Classic FM described sleigh bells and tubular bells as part of its orchestration.9

A federal court in Los Angeles considered the same question from a legal angle in 2025. Andy Stone, who performs as Vince Vance, and Troy Powers sued Carey and her co-writer Walter Afanasieff in 2023, claiming that the 1994 song copied their 1989 country song of the same title, and sought $20 million. On 19 March 2025, Judge Mónica Ramírez Almadani granted summary judgment to the defendants. According to the Associated Press, she agreed with the defence experts, who said that both songs used conventions of holiday songs that existed before either was written, and she sanctioned the plaintiffs and their lawyers, finding that the lawyers had made “no reasonable effort to ensure that the factual contentions asserted have evidentiary support”.12

Taken together, these sources describe a style more than a set of chords: bells, crooned melody over light orchestra, and words about home, snow and the season. The recordings that defined it, by Crosby, Cole and their contemporaries, were made between the 1940s and the 1960s. On this reading, which the sources support without proving, a new song is heard as a Christmas song to the degree that it reproduces that sound, and the new songs that have lasted, from Carey’s to Clarkson’s, use the bells and orchestral textures of the older records.

Streaming and the shape of December

The canon’s share of December has grown during the streaming era. The Hot 100 combines streaming, radio airplay and sales, and holiday songs have taken a larger share of it in each of the seasons for which records were found. In the chart published in the last week of December 2020, a record 39 holiday songs appeared, nine of them in the top ten, according to the Associated Press.6 In the chart dated 4 January 2025, holiday songs held every position from No. 1 to No. 16 and 42 places in all, and for the first time every song in the top ten was a holiday song.513 In the chart dated 3 January 2026, holiday songs held every position from No. 1 to No. 24.1

IV · THE CULTURE — ORPHEUS

The unbroken run of holiday songs from No. 1 on the Hot 100 grew from six to 24 in five seasons.
Billboard Hot 100 in the chart week covering Christmas: holiday songs at the top of the chart, 2020, 2024 and 2025 seasons
Season (chart)Holiday songs in top 10Unbroken run of holiday songs from No. 1Holiday songs on the chartPosition of “All I Want for Christmas Is You”
2020 (chart published week of 29 Dec 2020)9639 (then a record)No. 1
2024 (chart dated 4 Jan 2025)101642No. 1, 18th week
2025 (chart dated 3 Jan 2026)1024not reportedNo. 1, 22nd week
Source: Associated Press via WSBT, 29 December 2020; DJRob chart analysis, 31 December 2024; Uproxx, 30 December 2024; Top 40 Weekly, chart commentary for 3 January 2026. Run for 2020 computed by Titanica from the AP report that a non-holiday song stood at No. 7. Press reports of Billboard charts; the chart pages were not accessible. · Exhibit 04 · IV.OR.STRU.01

The songs that gained from this expansion were mostly old. Bobby Helms’s “Jingle Bell Rock”, first released in 1957, reached a new Hot 100 peak of No. 2 in the week of 27 December 2025, 67 years after its chart debut.14 Dean Martin’s “Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow!”, from 1959, reached No. 7 in the following week, its highest position on the chart, and Darlene Love’s “Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)”, from 1963, reached No. 14, her highest Hot 100 position.14 On the Holiday 100 for the same week, the only songs written after 1994 in the top 25 were “Santa Tell Me” and “Underneath the Tree”.3

This bears on the mechanism test. Streaming services offer seasonal playlists, and any design that draws on past listening rewards what listeners already know. If the services were selecting the canon, the expansion of the past five seasons could have gone to whichever recordings the services and their partners promoted. On the Holiday 100 for the week of 3 January 2026, 22 of the top 25 recordings were made before 1995, and the new Hot 100 peaks reported for that season went mainly to recordings made between 1957 and 1965. The December charts have amplified the canon, and they give no sign that streaming chose its members. The lag described above, in which new songs take a decade or more to rise, is the same process seen from the other side: repetition each December carries forward the songs that listeners already hold in memory, and adds new ones slowly as their first listeners grow up.

The canon as an asset

Investors have priced the standards as a durable source of income. The disclosed transactions in the most valuable recent standard all came after it reached No. 1.

IV · THE CULTURE — ORPHEUS

Three disclosed purchases of rights in one 1994 song all came after its first Hot 100 No. 1.
Disclosed transactions and legal events involving Christmas standards, 2019–2025
DateEventTerms disclosed
December 2019“All I Want for Christmas Is You” reaches No. 1 on the Hot 100 for the first time, 25 years after releasen/a
30 Sep 2020Hipgnosis Songs Fund acquires a stake in the song’s publishing as part of the catalogue of co-writer Walter AfanasieffSize of stake not disclosed
11 Oct 2021Primary Wave acquires an interest in Bing Crosby’s publishing, master recordings, film and television, name, likeness and brand rights, and archiveNot confirmed; reported by AP as more than $50 million
19 Mar 2025Federal court grants summary judgment to Carey and Afanasieff in a copyright suit seeking $20 millionPlaintiffs and lawyers sanctioned
27 Mar 2025ICM Crescendo Music Royalty Fund announces the acquisition of “certain publishing rights” in the songNot disclosed
18 Dec 2025A private fund advised by Pier Asset Management, through its unit Mooring Music Group, acquires a minority interest in the song’s royalty rightsNot disclosed
Source: Associated Press via WSBT, 29 December 2020; Music Business Worldwide, 14 December 2020; Digital Music News, 11 October 2021; Associated Press via Fox 10 Phoenix, 20 March 2025; ICM Asset Management, 27 March 2025; Mooring Music Group press release, PR Newswire, 18 December 2025. · Exhibit 05 · IV.OR.STRU.01

Hipgnosis Songs Fund, a listed investor in song rights, acquired its stake in the publishing of Carey’s song on 30 September 2020 as part of Walter Afanasieff’s catalogue, according to Music Business Worldwide.15 In December 2022, Reuters reported that Christmas songs, including Carey’s and Bublé’s, had helped the fund ahead of the holidays, and that its underlying net revenue had risen 5.8 per cent to $65.1 million in the six months to September.16 In October 2021, Primary Wave bought an interest in the estate of Bing Crosby covering his publishing, recordings, name and likeness and archive; the price was not confirmed, and the Associated Press reported it at more than $50 million.17 In March 2025, ICM Crescendo Music Royalty Fund announced that it had acquired “certain publishing rights” in Carey’s song, without naming a seller or a price.18 In December 2025, Mooring Music Group, which describes itself as the music royalties acquisition arm of Pier Asset Management, announced that a fund advised by Pier had acquired a minority interest in the song’s royalty rights. The release described Pier as “a private credit investment manager focused on asset-backed specialty finance”.2

The description places a share of the song’s income within asset-backed finance, the field that Pier names as its focus. The sequence of events matters for the mechanism test. The first disclosed purchase came nine months after the song’s first Hot 100 No. 1, and the two most recent came after six seasons at the top. In each case the buyers acquired a share of an income that the charts had already demonstrated. None of the transactions found for this Dispatch preceded the song’s rise.

The label credits on the Holiday 100 point the same way. The major record companies own both the old recordings and the new ones. Carey’s 1994 recording and Clarkson’s 2013 recording are both credited to labels of Sony Music, under Columbia/Legacy and 19/RCA/Legacy; Grande’s “Santa Tell Me” and Bobby Helms’s 1957 “Jingle Bell Rock” are both credited to labels that include UMe, Universal Music’s catalogue division; Sia’s “Snowman” and Bublé’s album are credited to Warner labels.3 An owner holding both kinds of recording has no evident reason to favour the older one, and the chart gives no sign that ownership determines which songs rise.

The case that the chart records defaults

The strongest objection is that a streaming chart in Christmas week measures what plays by default more than what people choose. The objection holds that in December holiday music plays in shops, offices and homes from playlists that listeners start and leave running, and that the order of those playlists is set by editors and algorithms that rank by past plays. On this view, the age of the canon reflects a feedback loop that rewards incumbency, and a chart built from such listening cannot distinguish the preferences of listeners from the design of the product.

The objection is serious, and the data used here cannot fully answer it. The Holiday 100 counts streams; it does not record whether a listener chose a song or let a playlist choose it. One fact limits the objection without removing it. The loop, if it decided membership, would make entry for new songs close to impossible, while the chart shows that songs such as “Underneath the Tree” and “Snowman” have entered and risen year by year. A feedback loop that rewards incumbency explains why entry is slow, and an account built on it alone has to allow for entry as well. The test of mechanism therefore favours a canon chosen first and amplified later, with the caveat that the amplification and the choice cannot be measured separately on the data available.

The season now beginning

In 2025 the Holiday 100 was already running by the week of 29 November, and the charts of the 2026 season will be measured against the one described here. On the evidence of the past season, the structure is stable at the top and changes at the margin. The first four places belong to records made between 1957 and 1994. On the Holiday 100, the positions from No. 11 to No. 25 belong, for now, entirely to songs written before 1980. The newer songs that have held their places use the sound of the older ones, and, if the generational account is right, their hold will grow as the listeners who heard them first as children reach adulthood.

The canon did not close in 1994. Its most successful member since then took 25 years to reach the top of the Hot 100, and the next two did their best on the Hot 100 a decade or more after release. Measured by the time a song needs to become a standard, Christmas music moves at the pace of a generation, and the buyers of its rights are paying for that pace.

  1. Top 40 Weekly, “Chart Commentary, January 3, 2026” (press report): Billboard Hot 100 dated 3 January 2026; seasonal songs at Nos. 1 to 24, surpassing the Nos. 1 to 16 of a year earlier; “All I Want for Christmas Is You” at No. 1 for a record 22nd week and in a seventh holiday season; “Santa Tell Me” at No. 5, “Underneath the Tree” at No. 8, “Jingle Bell Rock” at No. 3. https://top40weekly.com/chart-commentary-2026-01-03/ (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  2. Mooring Music Group, “Mooring Music Group Acquires Royalty Rights of Mariah Carey’s ‘All I Want for Christmas Is You'”, PR Newswire, Los Angeles, 18 December 2025, as republished by finanzen.net (company statement): acquisition of a minority interest in royalty rights of the song by a private fund advised by Pier Asset Management, described as “a private credit investment manager focused on asset-backed specialty finance”; Mooring described as Pier’s music royalties acquisition arm; terms not disclosed. https://www.finanzen.net/nachricht/aktien/mooring-music-group-acquires-royalty-rights-of-mariah-carey-s-all-i-want-for-christmas-is-you-15366967 (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  3. Billboard, “Holiday 100”, week of 3 January 2026 (industry chart, primary data): “ranked by streaming activity data by online music sources tracked by Luminate”; for each entry, last week’s position, peak, weeks on chart, debut and peak dates where shown, songwriter and label credits. https://www.billboard.com/?p=1479929 (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  4. Top 40 Weekly, “Chart Commentary, December 27, 2025” (press report): Billboard Hot 100 dated 27 December 2025; “Underneath the Tree” at No. 7, Kelly Clarkson’s highest-charting song since “Stronger (What Doesn’t Kill You)”; “Jingle Bell Rock” at No. 2. https://top40weekly.com/chart-commentary-2025-12-27/ (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  5. DJRob, analysis of the Billboard Hot 100 dated 4 January 2025, djrobblog.com, 31 December 2024 (commentary): holiday songs at Nos. 1 to 16 and 42 holiday entries in all; “Santa Tell Me” at No. 5 as the first 21st-century holiday song to reach the top five. https://djrobblog.com/archives/21731 (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  6. Associated Press, “A record 39 holiday songs dominate Billboard Hot 100 chart”, as published by WSBT, 29 December 2020 (press report): 39 holiday songs on the chart, nine in the top ten; “Mood” at No. 7; “All I Want for Christmas Is You” at No. 1, having reached No. 1 the previous year, 25 years after its 1994 release. https://wsbt.com/entertainment/a-record-39-holiday-songs-dominate-billboard-hot-100-chart (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  7. Carol L. Krumhansl and J. A. Zupnick, “Cascading reminiscence bumps in popular music”, Psychological Science, vol. 24, no. 10, 2013, doi:10.1177/0956797613486486 (peer-reviewed); summary in Association for Psychological Science release, 9 September 2013: 62 college-age participants, two top Billboard hits per year from 1955 to 2009. https://www.psychologicalscience.org/journals/psychological-science/0956797613486486/ and https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/513779 (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  8. ASCAP holiday song lists for 2025, as reported by BroadwayWorld, “Meghan Trainor, Kelly Clarkson & More Featured in the Top 10 ASCAP New Classic Holiday Songs Chart”, 11 December 2025 (press report): top 25 ASCAP holiday songs of 2025 and top 10 “new classic” holiday songs, with writers and years. https://www.broadwayworld.com/article/Meghan-Trainor-Kelly-Clarkson-More-Featured-in-the-Top-10-ASCAP-New-Classic-Holiday-Songs-Chart-20251211 (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  9. Kyle Macdonald, “A music theory analysis of Mariah Carey’s ‘All I Want For Christmas Is You'”, Classic FM, 19 December 2018 (press report): key of G major; 13 distinct chords according to a musicologist cited by Slate; half-diminished chord under “presents” credited by Slate and Vox; sleigh bells and tubular bells in the orchestration. https://classicfm.com/discover-music/music-theory/mariah-carey-all-i-want-for-christmas-analysis (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  10. Megan Lavengood, “What Makes It Sound Like Christmas?”, meganlavengood.com, 23 December 2016 (commentary): argues that the harmony of Christmas songs does not differ from comparable pop styles and that seasonal character comes from lyrics and timbre. https://wordpress.meganlavengood.com/2016/12/23/what-makes-it-sound-like-christmas/ (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  11. Samuel J. Bennett, Nottingham Trent University, “What makes a song sound christmassy: musicologist explains”, The Conversation, republished by Interaksyon, 19 December 2025 (commentary): sleigh bells as shorthand for Christmas; bell sounds in most of the UK’s 40 most-streamed Christmas songs; crooning voice and light orchestration; Bublé’s 2011 album. https://interaksyon.philstar.com/?p=306589 (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  12. Catherine Stoddard, FOX TV Digital, with the Associated Press, “Mariah Carey didn’t steal ‘All I Want for Christmas Is You,’ judge rules”, 20 March 2025 (press report): summary judgment for Carey and Afanasieff granted by Judge Mónica Ramírez Almadani on 19 March 2025 in the suit by Andy Stone and Troy Powers seeking $20 million; sanctions on plaintiffs and their lawyers. https://fox10phoenix.com/news/mariah-carey-didnt-steal-all-i-want-christmas-is-you-judge-rules (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  13. Uproxx, “It’s An All-Christmas Top 10 On The Billboard Hot 100 Chart For The First Time Ever”, 30 December 2024 (press report): every song in the top ten of the chart dated 4 January 2025 a holiday song; “All I Want for Christmas Is You” in an 18th week at No. 1. https://uproxx.com/pop/all-christmas-billboard-hot-100-chart (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  14. “Billboard Chart Thoughts: January 3, 2026”, xandrews.substack.com (commentary): “Jingle Bell Rock” reached a new peak of No. 2 the previous week, 67 years after its debut; “Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow!” at No. 7, its highest rank; “Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)” at No. 14, Darlene Love’s Hot 100 career peak. https://xandrews.substack.com/p/billboard-chart-thoughts-january (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  15. Music Business Worldwide, “As All I Want For Christmas Is You hits UK No.1, Hipgnosis backs fundraiser concert for Nordoff Robbins”, 14 December 2020 (press report): Hipgnosis Songs Fund acquired a stake in the song’s publishing on 30 September 2020 as part of Walter Afanasieff’s catalogue. https://www.musicbusinessworldwide.com/as-all-i-want-for-christmas-is-you-hits-uk-no-1-hipgnosis-backs-fundraiser-concert-for-nordoff-robbins (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  16. Reuters, “Christmas tracks bring cheer to music catalogue investor Hipgnosis”, 8 December 2022, as published by Yahoo Finance (press report): Carey’s and Bublé’s Christmas songs cited; underlying net revenue up 5.8% to $65.1 million in the six months to September. https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/news/christmas-tracks-bring-cheer-music-154935973.html (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  17. Digital Music News, report on Primary Wave’s acquisition of an interest in the Bing Crosby catalogue, 11 October 2021 (press report): publishing, master recording, film and television, name, likeness and brand rights and archive; price reported by the Associated Press as in excess of $50 million. https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2021/10/11/primary-wave-bing-crosby-deal/ (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
  18. ICM Asset Management, “ICM acquires rights to Mariah Carey’s iconic holiday anthem ‘All I Want for Christmas Is You'”, 27 March 2025 (company statement): acquisition by ICM Crescendo Music Royalty Fund of “certain publishing rights”; no seller or price stated. https://www.icmassetmanagement.com/icm-acquires-rights-to-mariah-careys-iconic-holiday-anthem-all-i-want-for-christmas-is-you/ (accessed 10 November 2026) ↩︎
Read through the Method
Context
Billboard's Holiday 100 for the week of 3 January 2026, ranked by Luminate streaming data and coded by Titanica by year of composition and recording; the Hot 100 in the Christmas weeks of 2020, 2024 and 2025; ASCAP's 2025 holiday lists; disclosed transactions in the rights to "All I Want for Christmas Is You" from 2020 to December 2025.
Causes
A recorded style of the 1940s to the 1960s (bells, crooned melody, light orchestra) that the lasting new songs reproduce; generational transmission of musical memory; the growth of holiday songs' share of December charts in the streaming era; investors' purchase of proven royalty streams.
Actors
Billboard and Luminate as measurers; ASCAP; Mariah Carey and Walter Afanasieff; the writers and performers of the standards; Hipgnosis Songs Fund, Primary Wave, ICM Crescendo Music Royalty Fund, Pier Asset Management and Mooring Music Group as buyers of rights; the federal court in Los Angeles that decided Stone v. Carey; music theorists and psychologists whose work is cited.
Perspectives
Separates compositions from recordings and the top of the chart from the rest; reports a narrowed thesis (a slow canon, open to new recordings of old songs); records the strongest counter-argument that streaming charts measure playlist defaults and states that the data cannot fully separate defaults from preferences; labels chart analyses, commentary and company statements; tests only the United States; makes no judgement of artists, owners or listeners.
Relationships
Opens the Orpheus Domain. Related: Dry Powder, AI's Money Loop Concentrates Risk on Few Balance Sheets (https://titani.ca/dispatch/ais-money-loop-concentrates-risk-on-few-balance-sheets/), on capital concentrating in proven assets; Zeitgeist, Is Islam Getting Cool? (https://titani.ca/dispatch/is-islam-getting-cool/), which links to Orpheus through music; Lumière, Netflix Is Selling the Same Hours for More (https://titani.ca/dispatch/netflix-selling-same-hours-for-more/), on streaming economics.

One phenomenon each morning. Free.